If there is a right, it can be implemented. To claim the right in court, if there is a right, the claim will be satisfied, if there is no right, the claim will be refused, as in this case A23-4671/2023. It is impossible to abuse the right.
On 02/20/2023, the judicial precinct No. 51 of the Kaluga Judicial District received a statement of claim from a Guide against Kaluga Astral JSC for the termination of the supply agreement and the refund of funds under the agreement.
On 02/27/2023, the statement of claim was returned, as the case falls within the jurisdiction of the arbitration court.
The individual entrepreneur I.P. Guide appealed to the Arbitration Court of the Kaluga region with a claim against Kaluga Astral JSC for recovery of the amount of advance payment under the supply agreement in the amount of 39,600 rubles, for termination of the supply agreement.
On January 29, 2024, the decision of the Administrative Court of the Kaluga Region dismissed the claim
On April 17, 2024, by resolution 20AAC, the decision of the Administrative Court of the Kaluga Region of January 29, 2024 in case No. A23-4671/2023 remained unchanged, and the Guide dismissed the appeal.
On 07/01/2024, the Court of Arbitration of the Kaluga Region recovered court costs in the amount of 70,000 rubles from the plaintiff in favor of a third party in the case.
07/15/2025 by the ruling of the Administrative Court of the Kaluga Region, 5,034.60 rubles were deducted from the plaintiff in favor of a third party-indexation of the court costs awarded by the ruling of 06/07/2024 in the amount of 70,000 rubles.